24-215 O - 78 - 19

The selection of any new technological endeavor, and in particular the selection of new space programs, must employ criteria with differing levels of importance and scope in a In considering candidate space programs, two classes of criteria are of particular importance: the basic criteria used to establish overall objectives in certain general areas, and the specific characteristics to be considered in selecting particular logical sequence. programs in these areas.

Basic selection criteria relate to overall program-area benefits and technological
feasibility. Primary, top-level concerns to be considered when addressing new areas
for technological advancement should include at least the potentials to improve the quality
of life on earth, solve a broad-scale technological problem, increase national security,
and advance knowledge. In addition to meeting as many of these criteria as possible, a
candidate program should be both practical and feasible, particularly from the technolog-
ical standpoint.

In sequential application of these criteria, it would first be determined if a particular
program appears to satisfy the requirement for producing substantial benefits in several
The assessment would then move forward to consider the
or all of the listed categories.

program's practicality and feasibility.

A key characteristic of programs that are designed to add to our existing knowledge is
that they always offer predictable benefits on which initial judgments can be based.
However, in our experience, such programs also produce substantial technological
benefits that could not be foreseen-and these benefits often equal or exceed those that
could be predicted.

14

FUTURE PROGRAM AREAS MUST SATISFY

BASIC SELECTION CRITERIA

Provide Substantial Benefit

■ Improve the Quality of Life

■Solve a Broad-Scale Technological Problem ■National Security

■ Advancement of Knowledge

Once overall program goals have been identified, more specific criteria should be used to
assess the desirability of candidate programs. Program characteristics that Mc Donnell
Douglas has found through experience to have a favorable effect on the attainment of
benefits, both predictable and unanticipated, include:

High Technology Content-Space programs high in technology content will be more
likely to produce important applications.

Ability to Stimulate Commercial Interest-Commercially attractive applications
derived from space programs will be exploited by private industry in a free-enter-
prise society. Therefore, programs with the highest probability of producing
commercially attractive applications should be given special consideration.
Emphasis on Maximum Use of Existing Resources - The Space Shuttle, for example,
is designed to provide convenient and inexpensive means for transporting men and
equipment to and from space. This long-sought capability is being developed at
great expense, and now is the time to select programs that will maximize its use.
Logical Evolution-Programs that exhibit evolutionary "building block" patterns
stimulate orderly advancement of capability and knowledge. We suggest that "proof
of concept" demonstration milestones be used to validate technological feasibility and
cost estimates as the program progresses, and to help ensure progression toward
the original objectives.

Flexibility to Meet User Requirements - The ability of the program to meet changing
user requirements is highly important. Programs should be structured to accept
variations in such requirements as orbital conditions, number of operators, time
on orbit, and data-handling capability.

Adaptability to Changing Conditions - Longer-term programs are sometimes subject
to significant changes in external conditions such as program priorities, budgets,
technological developments, political considerations, and national objectives.
Ability to adapt to such changes is essential.

Growth Potential-Future space programs will offer maximum growth potential if
modular growth is emphasized from the outset. Programs that exhibit modular
growth potential will permit natural evolution into further developments.

Affordability-Cost considerations need to be examined in relationship to potential
benefits, other competing requirements, and alternative means to the same end.

16

18