scenes.

by buoyant delight; he stayed and mused on painful But they did not make him angry. He was not irritated at the foolish fat scullion.' 1 He did not vex himself because of the vulgar. He did not amass petty details to prove that tenth-rate people were ever striving to be ninth-rate people. He had no tendency to rub the bloom off life. He accepted pretty-looking things, even the French aristocracy, and he owes his immortality to his making them prettier than they are. Thackeray was pained by things, and exaggerated their imperfections; Sterne brooded over things with joy or sorrow, and he idealised their sentiment their pathetic or joyful characteristics. This is why the old lady said, 'Mr. Thackeray was an uncomfortable writer,'and an uncomfortable writer he is.

Nor had Sterne a trace of Mr. Thackeray's peculiar and characteristic scepticism. He accepted simply the pains and pleasures, the sorrows and the joys of the world; he was not perplexed by them, nor did he seek to explain them, or account for them. There is a tinge-a mitigated, but perceptible tinge-of Swift's philosophy in Thackeray. Why is all this? Surely this is very strange ? Am I right in sympathising with such stupid sensations? Why are these things?

feelings, such petty Am I not a

fool to care about or think of them? The world is dark, and the great curtain hides from us all.' This is not a steady or a habitual feeling, but it is never quite absent for many pages. It was inevitable, perhaps, that in a sceptical and inquisitive age like this, some vestiges of puzzle and perplexity should pass into the writings of our great sentimentalist. He would not have fairly represented the moods of his time if he omitted that pervading one.

1 Tristram Shandy, vol. v. chap. vii.

We had a little more to say of these great men, but our limits are exhausted, and we must pause. Of Thackeray it is too early to speak at length. A certain distance is needful for a just criticism. The present generation have learned too much from him to be able to judge him rightly. We do not know the merit of those great pictures which have sunk into our minds, and which have coloured our thoughts, which are become habitual memories. In the books we know best, as in the people we know best, small points, sometimes minor merits, sometimes small faults, have an undue prominence. When the young critics of this year [1864] have grey hairs, their children will tell them what is the judgment of posterity upon Mr. Thackeray.

GENERAL INDEX

TO VOLS. I. AND II.

Addison, ii. 208.

Amplification, sermonic, i. 213.
Aristotle, cited, i. 104, 105 n.,
115; ii. 2.

Arnold, Matthew, i. 231, 249;

ii. 163 n., 277.
Arnold, Thomas, cited, i. 108.
Art, ancient and modern, i. 197.
Austen, Jane, i. 82.

Calvinism, i. 73.
Campbell, Chief Justice. ii. 97-8.
Carlyle, Thomas, startles like a
comet, i. 21; master of de-
lineative conjecture, 166; on
poetry, 221; his sympathy
with Cromwell, ii. 83.

cited, i. 162; ii. 13, 29, 79,

193.
Cavaliers, the, ii. 78-83, 141.

Bacon, Lord, ii. 77; cited, i. Cervantes, ii. 115.

105 n., 121, 157.

Beaumont and Fletcher, i. 250.
Bentham, Jeremy, ii. 8.
Bentley, Richard, i. 48.
Biography: delineation of char-
aoter, i. 23; exhaustive or
selective, 102, 161-3.
Bookish scholasticism, i. 243.
Books, for various purposes,
i. 20; of travel, ii. 233.
Brougham, Lord, i. 209.
Browning, Robert, i. 218 ff.
Burke, Edmund, i. 191;
94-5; cited, ii. 269.

ii.

and Macaulay contrasted,
ii. 95.

Burnet, Bishop, ii. 210.
Burns, Robert, i. 148; cited,
i. 76.

Business of Life (the) and the
novelists, ii. 170.

Butler, Bishop, i. 214; cited,
ii. 106.

Byron, Lord, i. 145, 160; ii.
122, 232; cited, i. 6; ii. 81,

201.

VOL. II.-19

Character, delineation of, i. 23;
ii. 105.

"vivification" of, ii. 174.
Chaucer, i. 24; ii. 164-5.
Chesterfield, Lord, cited, ii. 41.
Christianity, ii. 51.

Church, the primitive, ii. 55.
Civilisation, Jewish, i. 122;
Pagan, i. 122.

Clarendon, Lord, ii. 78.

Classical Style, simplicity of,
i. 151.

Clough, A. H., i. 275.
Cobbett, William, cited, i. 98.
COLERIDGE, HARTLEY, essay on,
i. 1 ff., 229, 230.

S. T., conversation of,
i. 9; infirmity of, 17; pro-
vides for Hartley Coleridge,
22; early poems of, 29, 30;
and Paradise Lost, 212; and
fairy tales, ii. 8; on transla-
tions of poetry, 157.
Committee system, i. 193.
Conscience, i. 121; the convert-
ing intuition, i. 122.

"Experiencing Nature," an, ii. Ill-temper, i. 175.