How the Dismal Science Got Its Name: Classical Economics and the Ur-text of Racial Politics
University of Michigan Press, 2001 - 320 páginas
It is widely asserted that the Victorian sages attacked classical economics from a humanistic or egalitarian perspective, calling it "the dismal science," and that their attack is relevant to modern discussions of market society. David M. Levy here demonstrates that these assertions are simply false: political economy became "dismal" because Carlyle, Ruskin, and Dickens were horrified at the idea that systems of slavery were being replaced by systems in which individuals were allowed to choose their own paths in life. At a minimum, they argued, "we" white people ought to be directing the lives of "them," people of color.
Economists of the time argued, on the other hand, that people of color were to be protected by the rule of law--hence the moniker "the dismal science."
A startling image from 1893, which is reproduced in full color on this book's jacket, shows Ruskin killing someone who appears to be nonwhite. A close look reveals that the victim is reading "The Dismal Science."
Levy discusses this image at length and also includes in his text weblinks to Carlyle's "Occasional Discourse on the Negro Question" and to Mill's response, demonstrating that these are central documents in British classical economics. He explains Adam Smith's egalitarian foundations, contrasting Smith's approach to the hierarchical alternative proposed by Carlyle. Levy also examines various visual representations of this debate and provides an illuminating discussion of Smith's "katallactics," the science of exchange, comparing it with the foundations of modern neoclassical economics.
How the Dismal Science Got Its Name also introduces the notion of "rational choice scholarship" to explain how attacks on market economics from a context in which racial slavery was idealized have been interpreted as attacks on market economics from a humanistic or egalitarian context. Thus it will greatly appeal to economists, political scientists, philosophers, students of Victorian literature, and historians.
David M. Levy is Associate Professor of Economics and Research Associate, Center for Study of Public Choice, George Mason University.
Comentarios de la gente - Escribir un comentario
No encontramos ningún comentario en los lugares habituales.
Poets Come Bringing Death to Friends of the Dismal Science
Ecce Homo Symbols Make the Man
Beginning with an Exchange or with a Command?
A Rational Choice Approach to Scholarship
Market Order or Hierarchy?
Debating Racial Quackery
Economic Texts as Apocrypha
Hard Times and the Moral Equivalence of Markets and Slavery
Exchange between Actor and Spectator
The Partial Spectator in the Wealth of Nations A Robust Utilitarianism
Katallactic Rationality Language Approbation and Exchange
Adam Smiths Rational Choice Linguistics
Bishop Berkeley Exorcises the Infinite
The Katallactic Moment
Otras ediciones - Ver todas
How the Dismal Science Got Its Name: Classical Economics and the Ur-text of ...
David M. Levy
Vista de fragmentos - 2001
Términos y frases comunes
Adam American approbation argue argument attack become believe Berkeley Berkeley's better British called Carlyle Carlyle's chapter choice Christian claim classical common consider context course criticism debate described Dickens discussion dismal doctrine economics economists edition English equal evidence exchange existence expected explain fact George give greatest happiness Hard human important individual interest interpretation issue John judgment labour language less Levy live London masters mean Mill moral nature Negro object observe past perhaps person political position possible present Press principle problem propose question quoted race racial rational reader reason reference response Review Ruskin scholars seems sense slavery slaves Smith social society spectator supposed texts theory things thought tion trade understand University utilitarianism Wealth of Nations well-being
Referencias a este libro
The Origin of Wealth: Evolution, Complexity, and the Radical Remaking of ...
Eric D. Beinhocker
Vista previa limitada - 2006
Todos los resultados de la Búsqueda de libros »
The Cult of Statistical Significance: How the Standard Error Costs Us Jobs ...
Steve Ziliak,Deirdre Nansen McCloskey
Vista previa limitada - 2008