IN THE

SUPREME COURT

OF THE

UNITED STATES

167, 168, 169, 170 U. S.

BOOK 42,

LAWYERS' EDITION,

CITED "LAW. ED."

COMPLETE WITH Head LineS, HEAD NOTES, STATEMENTS OF CASES, POINTS AND
AUTHORITIES OF COUNSEL, FOOT NOTES AND PARALLEL REFERENCES

BY

STEPHEN K. WILLIAMS, LL.D.

LAWYERS CO-OPERATIVE PUBLISHING COMPANY,

ROCHESTER, NEW YORK

COPYRIGHT © 1898 BY

THE LAWYERS CO-OPERATIVE PUBLISHING CO.

COYRIGHT RENEWED 1926

THE LAWYERS CO-OPERATIVE PUBLISHING CO.

42 L ed

3. Appointed to succeed Judge McKenna: Commission recorded Feb. 21, 1888.